Worth the Fee

Rakuten or TopCashback: which pays more, and how do payouts differ?

Facts checked November 20, 20264 min readHow we check facts

This page contains a referral link. We earn points or cash if you sign up through it. How we earn.

The short answer

Neither site pays more at every store; rates on both change often, so the higher one depends on the store and the day. The clearer difference is the payout: Rakuten pays on four fixed dates once you have about $5 confirmed, while TopCashback lets you cash out on request once cash back is marked available.

Referral link: we earn if you sign up. Read the page first. Join Rakuten with the bonus

This page is information, not financial advice.

Payouts side by side

Rakuten TopCashback
Cost to join Free Free
When you are paid February 15, May 15, August 15, November 15 Any time, once cash back is "available"
Minimum About $5 confirmed ($5 on one Rakuten page, $5.01 in its terms) None, per The Points Guy; some gift cards may have one
Cash methods Check, PayPal Bank transfer, Venmo, PayPal
Other methods Amex Membership Rewards points, Bilt points, Samsung Cash, gift cards Gift cards; prepaid cards
Wait before money is yours Typically 3 to 14 weeks to confirm, then the next date Set by each store; up to 90 days, per The Points Guy

TopCashback's own help page says each store has a different period before cash back becomes available. Travel becomes available only after the stay is complete.

How many days a TopCashback transfer takes after you request it is not confirmed; its help pages do not give a figure.

For Rakuten's schedule in detail, see when Rakuten pays.

Which pays more?

There is no fixed answer. Three things are known:

  • NerdWallet's comparison says TopCashback's rates are often higher than Rakuten's.
  • One personal finance blog tracked 15 stores during 2025. It found TopCashback higher at 10, Rakuten higher at 4, and one tie. That is one writer's unverified test.
  • Rakuten often raises a store's rate for a short time. In early November 2026 it ran ten one-day offers at rates from 12% to 30%, according to Upgraded Points.

Rakuten's terms also say rates are personalized and may differ between members. The practical step is to look at both sites on the day you buy.

TopCashback's rate guarantee

TopCashback has a Highest Cash Back Guarantee. Its help page describes the steps: buy through TopCashback, file a claim once the cash back has tracked, and it will beat the other offer after approving the claim.

The Points Guy lists the conditions, as of its November 2025 article:

  • It covers higher rates from eight named competitors, Rakuten among them.
  • The higher rate must have been on offer the same day as your purchase.
  • The claim must be filed within seven days.
  • It matches cash rates only, not points or miles.

The full terms sit behind a sign-in and were not read for this page.

Where Rakuten differs

Rakuten can pay in American Express Membership Rewards points at 1 point per cent, if you hold an eligible card. A reader who gets more than 1 cent of value from a point comes out ahead of the same rate paid in cash. TopCashback's guarantee does not match points. See whether Amex points are worth more than cash.

Where TopCashback differs

  • No fixed payment dates.
  • Bank transfer and Venmo are payout choices.
  • The Points Guy says some payouts taken as store credit or a prepaid card usually come with a bonus of up to 5%, at certain merchants.

Can you use both?

You can hold both accounts. One order can be tracked by only one of them. Rakuten's help center says a click from another rewards site disables its cash back, and it asks members to turn off competing extensions. Pick one before you add items to the cart.

Where sources disagree

  • Payout methods. TopCashback's help page lists bank, Venmo, PayPal and gift cards. One blog also lists a paper check, which TopCashback's page does not mention.
  • Minimums. The Points Guy says TopCashback has none. Other summaries say some gift card options start at a few dollars.

Who should skip it

  • Skip Rakuten for a given order if TopCashback's rate is clearly higher that day and you want cash.
  • Skip TopCashback if you collect Amex points; it pays cash and gift cards.

Quick answers

Does TopCashback have a minimum payout? The Points Guy says no. Some gift card options may have their own minimum.

How often does Rakuten pay? Four times a year: February 15, May 15, August 15 and November 15.

Can I get cash back from both on one order? No. Only one site can track a purchase. Choose one before you shop.

Sources

Referral link

Rakuten

When checked on November 20, 2026, Rakuten's referral offer was a $50 bonus after you join and spend $50 on qualifying purchases within 90 days.

Join Rakuten with the bonus

If you qualify, the person who runs this site also gets a $50 bonus from Rakuten. It costs you nothing extra. How we earn.