Worth the Fee

When should you pay with points, and when with cash?

Facts checked November 20, 20265 min readHow we check facts

This page contains a referral link. We earn points or cash if you sign up through it. How we earn.

The short answer

Work out cents per point: take the cash price, subtract the taxes and fees you still pay on the award, and divide by the points needed. If the answer is below what your points fetch the simple way (1 cent for Chase, 0.6 to 1 cent for Amex), pay cash. If it is above the 1.7 to 2 cents that published valuations use, points are doing well.

Referral links: we earn if you sign up. Read the page first. See your Amex offer See the Chase Sapphire offer

This page is information, not financial advice.

The check, in three steps

  1. Find the cash price of the exact flight or room, on the same dates.
  2. Find the points price, and the taxes, fees and surcharges charged with it.
  3. Cents per point = (cash price minus award taxes and fees) divided by points, times 100.

Use a cash price you would in fact pay. A $6,000 business-class fare you would never buy does not make your points worth 6 cents each to you.

What to compare the answer with

Yardstick Amex points Chase points Source
The floor: cash or statement credit 0.6 cents 1 cent The Points Guy, CNBC Select
Flights through the card's travel site 1 cent 1 cent; up to 2 cents with a Points Boost on a Sapphire Reserve The Points Guy, Chase
Published average through transfer partners 2.0 cents (The Points Guy); 1.7 cents (One Mile at a Time) 2.05 cents (The Points Guy); 1.7 cents (One Mile at a Time) November 2026 valuations

Reading the result:

  • Below the floor. Pay cash. The points would buy more as a plain credit or travel-site booking.
  • Between the floor and about 1.7 cents. A fair use, not a strong one. Paying with points makes sense if you have more points than plans for them.
  • About 1.7 to 2 cents or more. In line with or above what experienced users average.

The floors come from what an Amex point is worth and Chase's Points Boost.

Three worked examples

The award prices are from the sources named. The cash fares are illustrations, not quotes.

Booking Points and fees (source) Cash fare (illustration) Cents per point
Flying Blue business class, US to Europe, one way 60,000 miles plus $608 (Flying Blue's example, via The Points Guy) $2,400 (2,400 − 608) ÷ 60,000 = 2.99
The same seat during a fare sale 60,000 miles plus $608 $1,300 (1,300 − 608) ÷ 60,000 = 1.15
50,000 Amex points moved to Hilton (100,000 Hilton points) No fees $400 of hotel nights, at The Points Guy's 0.4 cents per Hilton point 400 ÷ 50,000 = 0.8

The first is a strong use. The second barely beats booking through the travel site. The third is below the 1 cent that Amex Travel gives on flights, so those points would go further on airfare.

Three things the sum leaves out

Points you do not earn. A cash ticket earns points; an award ticket does not. The Platinum Card earns 5 points per dollar on flights booked with airlines or Amex Travel. On a $1,000 fare that is 5,000 points, worth $50 to $100 at 1 to 2 cents each. Award tickets also usually earn no airline miles.

Taxes and surcharges. They vary widely. The Points Guy puts a Virgin Atlantic business-class award from New York to London at 29,000 points plus about $700 one way. Leave that out and the sum flatters the award.

Flexibility. A transfer to an airline cannot be reversed, and the miles then follow that airline's rules. Flying Blue's lowest award fares, sold since September 8, 2026, allow no changes or refunds.

When cash is usually right

  • Low fares. As an illustration, a $250 domestic ticket priced at 25,000 miles is 1 cent per point before fees.
  • Hotel transfers other than Hyatt. The Points Guy values Marriott at 0.75 cents, IHG at 0.6, Hilton at 0.4 and Wyndham at 0.55 per point.
  • Gift cards and checkout purchases with Amex points, at 0.5 to 1 cent.
  • Any trip where the award surcharge is close to the cash fare.

When points are usually right

  • Long-haul business class with an open award seat. See the prices for Europe and Japan.
  • Economy on dates when cash fares are high but the award price is fixed.
  • Hyatt nights from a Sapphire Reserve at 1 to 1; The Points Guy values a Hyatt point at 1.65 cents.

Which partners clear the bar most often: Chase partners and Amex partners.

Who should skip the math

  • People with a cash-back card. There is nothing to compare.
  • People who hold few points and have no trip planned. Points do not earn interest, and programs can raise award prices without notice.
  • People who value simplicity over the last half cent. Booking through the travel site at 1 cent takes no award search.

Quick answers

What is a good cents-per-point value? Above about 1.7 to 2 cents matches the published averages for Amex and Chase points. Above the 1 cent travel-site rate is acceptable.

Should taxes be subtracted first? Yes. Subtract the taxes and fees charged on the award from the cash price before dividing by the points.

Is it wrong to use points at 1 cent? No. It is the base travel-site rate for both programs. It is simply not more than the simple option gives.

Sources

Referral link

American Express Platinum Card

Amex shows you your own welcome offer before you apply. The referral page says "as high as 175,000" Membership Rewards points; yours may be lower. From the same page you can choose a different Amex card.

See your Amex offer

If you are approved, the person who runs this site earns Membership Rewards points from Amex. It costs you nothing extra. How we earn.

Referral link

Chase Sapphire cards

When checked on November 20, 2026, the referral page showed 75,000 bonus points on Sapphire Preferred after $5,000 of purchases in the first 3 months. Offers change, so read the page.

See the Chase Sapphire offer

If you are approved, the person who runs this site earns Chase points. It costs you nothing extra. How we earn.